Comment posted on Sunday Coffee with Ana: DoFollow, NoFollow and More by Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark
Whoa, wait a sec..hold the phone…please do not tell me you just said “without comment links, link building is dead” please don’t tell me you even came close to saying that?!?!?!?!
FYI: Link wheels are on the no no list now.
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark also commented
- I’m keeping your info as well Ian. Love the banners.
- I’m not sure you’ve even seen the new theme yet, over the past week or more it has been up and down due to issues…look now and tell me what you see, I’ll tell you if it’s the right one. lol
- Comment-ping question…..any idea how to get the link back after closing the page?
- Golly, “experts” wrong again, what a shocker.
DennisEdell.com went from PR1 to PR3 in the one update. CONTENT is what it is all about…links help too.
Over the last year or so, Google has been quite vocal about the fact that comments links are losing value…soon probably none, they pay very little attention to it now.
FYI: Blog commenting has not been a good source for backlinks in quite a while, and shouldn’t be used for such.
Thanks for Ian’s link, that was my first question!
Thanks for the awesome comment-ping tip, I’ll start that now!
Finally, and a little off-topic (saving an email) - the new theme is up and running, sorry for the delay, I talk a bit bout it here - http://www.dennisedell.com/10733/new-year-new-theme-new-plans-oh-my/ - you can easing see why a review at this time would be useless or at least really short. LOL!
Recent comments by Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark
- Best Aweber Autoresponder Review? You bet!
Excellent review for an excellent service, I’ve used them for years.Check your links ASAP Ana, their broken.
- How to Build a List? See Beyond The List To Make The Real Money
#’s 4-5……On my first list set up, eons ago i was all excited to do these things. I was told not to spend much time on them though. Most folks know to just look for links and don’t read them much.Thoughts?
- Blog Comment Traffic Research: Signed, Sealed, and Delivered
Known around town as a tried and true comment commando, I’m really glad to see others learning what I’ve been saying for years.
It works!On my last blog, for nearly 2yrs it was my ONLY promotional method.
At the time, return comments were my only metric. With nearly 8000 comments on approximately 200 posts, I concluded…..yea, it worked pretty well.
Of course, to use comments as metric, you also need a kick-butt title with a call to action to match.
- Dofollow Nofollow Links: Is There a Happy Medium?
Good to know.Btw, in regards to keeping the KWL plugin even though it is rendered useless…I kinda liked your point of view..keeping it for the sole purpose of commenters separating name from kw.
- Dofollow Nofollow Links: Is There a Happy Medium?
It’s not for me, that’s definitely something I’d need more then a guess on.My commenters, not to mention my blog itself is far too important to me to wager on, just in case I wanted to delete a simple plugin.
powered by SEO Super Comments
Article by Ana Hoffman
Ana is the founder of Traffic Generation Cafe and wants you to know that Thesis + Scribe = SEO Made Simple. Get more from Ana on Facebook or Twitter.
More Great Posts on the Topic:
- Does NoFollow Follow? Blog commenting is a great way to drive targeted traffic to your site, as well as create great backlinks. However,...
- Sunday Coffee With Ana: Here’s What You Missed This Morning Oh, my, oh, my… My first live broadcast turned out to be a huge success! What I loved about it:...
- DoFollow Express: Is Traffic Generation Cafe Getting Off? If you’ve been a regular reader of Traffic Generation Cafe for any length of time, you know where I stand...
- Dofollow Nofollow Links: Is There a Happy Medium? With the recent PageRank update, many bloggers panicked and started taking some radical measures like making their blogs nofollow and...
- Sunday Coffee with Ana: Start Engaging Others or No SEO Will Help As most of you know, there won’t be a live Sunday Coffee with Ana broadcast today. I know you are...
Traffic Generation Cafe happily runs on Thesis Theme
What do I love about Thesis? Everything would be the short answer.
If that doesn't work for you, then the fact that Thesis Theme framework is designed to serve is the rock-solid foundation for any website. My Traffic Generation Cafe and I fully trust and rely on the airtight SEO, incredible design flexibility, and lightning-fast loading times that Thesis provides.
Still not sure about Thesis? See what you can do with it, then decide.
- Thesis Gallery - Lots of well designed blogs powered by Thesis
- Thesis Awesome - AMAZING customization packages for Thesis
- Thesis User Guide - see how much incredible support you get
{ 36 comments }
Thanks for the shout out Ana! Yeah, it was no problem helping Linda, she’s really nice. That’s what blogging should be about anyways, helping other people
Ben´s last blog ..Quoracom – Is it The Death of Yahoo Answers
Comment-ping question…..any idea how to get the link back after closing the page?
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark´s last blog ..Feb Comment Contest- 4 Days to Get in the Top 9! – - Looking for March Sponsors!
Not sure you can…
Ana´s last blog ..Dofollow Nofollow Links- Is There a Happy Medium
Golly, “experts” wrong again, what a shocker.
DennisEdell.com went from PR1 to PR3 in the one update. CONTENT is what it is all about…links help too.
Over the last year or so, Google has been quite vocal about the fact that comments links are losing value…soon probably none, they pay very little attention to it now.
FYI: Blog commenting has not been a good source for backlinks in quite a while, and shouldn’t be used for such.
Thanks for Ian’s link, that was my first question!
Thanks for the awesome comment-ping tip, I’ll start that now!
Finally, and a little off-topic (saving an email) - the new theme is up and running, sorry for the delay, I talk a bit bout it here - http://www.dennisedell.com/10733/new-year-new-theme-new-plans-oh-my/ - you can easing see why a review at this time would be useless or at least really short. LOL!
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark´s last blog ..Feb Comment Contest- 4 Days to Get in the Top 9! – - Looking for March Sponsors!
I do expect Google to pay less and less attention to comment links. Good thing and bad thing: where does it leave us, average bloggers, as far as link building? Link wheels?
Who know…
Off the check out your new site!
Ana´s last blog ..How Two Days Without Internet Made Me Stumble Upon a Great Idea
Not too much new…. yet?
I’m not sure you’ve even seen the new theme yet, over the past week or more it has been up and down due to issues…look now and tell me what you see, I’ll tell you if it’s the right one. lol
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark´s last blog ..Should Guest Bloggers be Responsible for Their Own SEO
Whoa, wait a sec..hold the phone…please do not tell me you just said “without comment links, link building is dead” please don’t tell me you even came close to saying that?!?!?!?!
FYI: Link wheels are on the no no list now.
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark´s last blog ..Should Guest Bloggers be Responsible for Their Own SEO
Hey Ana,
Thanks for the mention and link in your post today. Really appreciate it. I missed morning coffee yesterday
Have to catch next weeks.
Great advice on pinging comments, I had no idea, guess I will have to try it.
Thanks again Ana and have a great day!!
Ian Belanger@Network Marketing Success´s last blog ..7 Characteristics of an Online Entrepreneur Leader
Thank YOU, Ian, and I might have more requests coming your way soon.
Ana´s last blog ..Search Engine Ranking Tip- How to Search Google Incognito
I’m keeping your info as well Ian. Love the banners.
Dennis Edell@ Direct SalesMark´s last blog ..Should Guest Bloggers be Responsible for Their Own SEO
I like your hair and your picture so I don’t know what anyone is complaining about. If it was some cartoon or something that didn’t look like you that would be another matter. Now to the real commenting.
Perhaps it’s me but I’ve never relied wholly on organic search or Google for my traffic. My strategy includes a lot of targeted networking and commenting along with a healthy dose of SEO. Until I read about PageRank here I had forgotten about it
Also, and I’m going to talk about me here, for my blog I have CommentLuv et al installed and have it all dofollow. The only thing I make nofollow is some outbound links (affiliate stuff) and links to certain pages (about, contact). Other than that if link juice goes I guess it goes. My blog isn’t 100% of my marketing or income, only one stream. So with diversity in place I can focus on the overall strategy, community building, and providing massive value to all of my readers and subscribers.
Robert Dempsey@Internet Marketing Strategies´s last blog ..Is Social Media A Waste Of Your Time
Hey Robert,
I’m with you about not focusing solely on organic search. It’s important to use other effective sources of traffic generation.
Social media is red HOT right now and it offers free “word of mouth” advertising. We still need to get out there and network with others. This exactly how I’m getting a flood of traffic from Facebook!
All the best,
Mavis
Mavis Nong @ Attraction Marketing´s last blog ..How To Speed Up Your Blog So You Stop Annoying Your Visitors
I’m interested in talking with you more about this Mavis. I’m heading over to your site to learn more. It would be great to hear your experience first hand (say via Skype) sometime with this. I’m close to having an epiphany when it comes to using Facebook and Twitter. I’ve been on both for years and am a huge fan.
Robert Dempsey´s last blog ..Is Social Media A Waste Of Your Time
Love seeing this kind of networking on my blog, although makes me feel left out.
You’d be surprised to know how many emails and comments I get solely talking about my hair, Robert.
Agreed on your points re: SEO. I am sensible with it, do common-sense things, but don’t go overboard. Actually, don’t have time even if I wanted to.
Ana´s last blog ..How KeywordLuv Can Get You on the First Page of Google
I give it to you, you are the Queen of networking Ana. There are only a handful of bloggers that take time to answer all their comments and looking around, I think they are mostly influenced by you. If I talk to a wall when I comment on a blog, I will not comment on that blog even if it is dofollow to the 3rd order. The only exception is when I see that a lot of commenters are asking questions without getting answers from the blog owner and I have the answer to their questions, I will then step in and help out or when I want to engage with the other commenters. I will understand though when in the future, you can’t meet up with replying all the comments because they are just too much (look what is happening now
cos you went away for a few days!).
I like your new side banners better. Maybe because it is not generic. And it caught my attention the first day you put them up and that’s what you want, isn’t it?
Talking about design, did you create your opt-in form using Aweber forms or did you design it yourself? I had a look at their forms and they were too generic and they say you can edit them, still I’m curious. And pls which software did you use to create you e-book image? I love it.
Thanks for the pinging comments tip, it will be very handy. Though I’m sure you know this already, I find that my comments on your blog are indexed quickly, I guess it is because you update very often and crawlers come by on their own.
Alexa ranking: What tip do you have for people in a non-techy niche? Alexa ranking is mostly based on traffic from browsers with Alexa Toolbar installed. In some niches, the only traffic from a browser with Alexa toolbar maybe from the blog/site owner himself!
I got to run … my babies are calling.
Keep up the good work.
I am so with you regarding your commenting remarks, Maky.
A lot of times I won’t comment on a blog simply because the blogger is not returning the comments. My thought is “why waste your breath?” Unless, you are link building of course.
Sorry to say I won’t be able to help you as far as your design questions go - I had a designer do it all for me. However, it looks to me like Ian Belanger who I mentioned in the post is more than capable to do it. I loved working with him.
You are right, my blog is crawled daily, so pinging the comments on my blogs is a bit of a waste of time.
I’d say not to worry about your Alexa rank. It’s like PR in most cases - everybody know it’s all frivolous, yet everybody pays attention to the numbers.
Just track your traffic through Google Analytics and make sure it grows.
My 3 year-old is peacefully asleep giving me some much needed time to catch up!
Ana´s last blog ..Anyone Should Blog 3 Types of Blogs and 3 Ways to Handle Them
Lucky you! I have a 3yr old that is more of a baby than my 3 month old
Thanks for the answers but no thanks for making me feel good about my Alexa rank
Hi Ana,
At point #5 you want to say if the comment is showing “waiting for moderation” and still I ping that comment then it will instantly crawled by search engines(Google, Yahoo, Bing etc). Am I correct?
Priya @ Goa Carnival´s last blog ..Goa Carnival Date 2011 5th to 8th March
Technically, the comment is there, it’s just not visible to the reader - you.
Plus, when you ping something, it doesn’t mean that it will be crawled instantly, of course. So by the time, the SE spider gets to the comment, it might actually be approved by then.
Either way, I always do it. Doesn’t take but a second.
Ana´s last blog ..Anyone Should Blog 3 Types of Blogs and 3 Ways to Handle Them
I got the point here, thanks for explaining it.
Priya @ Goa Carnival´s last blog ..Goa Carnival Date 2011 5th to 8th March
Hey Ana
I learned a lot about dofollow and nofollow…that things is very effective for website/blog but now many websites changed her status into nofollow..why? in my opinion websites owner thinks that other websites take benefits form her websites that’s why they changed status.
@Facebook Applications That’s correct, people thought they’d get more benefits and higher PageRank by switching to NoFollow. But that’s not necessarily the case.
My blog is a DoFollow with PR4. And the recent changes haven’t affected my PR.
All the best,
Mavis
Mavis Nong @ Attraction Marketing´s last blog ..How To Speed Up Your Blog So You Stop Annoying Your Visitors
Hey Mavis
I like your comment but why people switching do follow tag to nofollow tag.Every one know about do follow value.
And you mention that your blog is do follow..why you put your blog in do follow tag.Any reason “Mavis”..I know do follow is important but google check this tag while they inspect website either that website is do follow/no follow.I think no!
Facebook Applications´s last blog ..Introducing the Facebook Photo Theater- Here to Stay whether we “Like it” or Not!
Thanks for jumping in, Mavis!
Roses Mark - these are precisely the points we discussed in the post above.
Ana´s last blog ..Dofollow Nofollow Links- Is There a Happy Medium
I would quite happily forget all about SEO practices and just focus on content, content, content! But I’m not that naive. I know SEO has a major part to play in pushing my blog forward and promoting all that juicy content I write
I guess the trick is to find your ideal balance. What works for someone else may not work for you, and vice-versa. But experiment with what feels right, and don’t be afraid to try a new approach that you haven’t come across before. If it works for you, then it works, period.
Stuart´s last blog ..Let’s Talk About Happiness
I am actually with you, Stuart. I am an SEO user, not more than that.
I use it to the extent that it helps me get more search engine traffic, but I am definitely not obsessed with it.
I’d love to just focus on content, but then nobody will ever find me.
Ana´s last blog ..List Building- When I Want Your Opinion- I’ll Ask for It… Asking Now
Ana,
Thanks for posting your broadcast. I like the color and tone of your new banners. They are not too bright.
I missed the ping your comments tip last time, appreciate the update.
Looking forward to the DoFollow post.
Sheila Atwood@landing pages best practices´s last blog ..How About a Chocolate Donut A Danish- Maybe
Thanks, Sheila, and glad you like the new banners. Now I am anxious to see if they actually produce better results.
Ana´s last blog ..Sunday Coffee with Ana- DoFollow- NoFollow and More
Far out! You fall asleep putting your kid down and this is what you miss!?! Sorry I missed the coffee this morning, now I’m really annoyed lol. Between you, Gail @growmap and Satish? @seommotips I am questioning my tactics and I’m also surprised how much people care.
I’ve since learned that commentluv is dofollow (I think, Andy Bailey says it depends on blog settings, but mine are still do follow so beats me!
Definitely looking forward to the posts this week and the ensuing conversation.
Alex´s last blog ..Who Stole My Pagerank
Hi Alex,
Some bloggers do admit to manually editing it to become nofollow once they step on the PR ladder. But as Ana mentioned, she does not care cos she is still down with us mortals at PR0
But the question is … Does having a dofollow blog while at PR0 affect how long it will take to become ranked? Maybe Ana will answer that on Tuesday’s post?
Lack of PR is not preventing Google from crawling my blog on a daily basis and indexing over 2000 pages by now.
So I still get a lot of Google love in terms of spiders and rankings, plus my readers love me - now can I go wrong?
Ana´s last blog ..How to Track and Manage Your Traffic Generation Efforts
Hi Ana,
I missed your broadcast this morning
I had to blow snow out of my driveway…we had over a foot this week. I think your whole blog looks bigger and I like it that way. I’d get a 3x Giant Print Bible, but I think it would be too heavy too carry around with all thos extra pages. It gets that way at my age and bifocals. I hope you continue to have a blog audit on Friday, that is a great feature. I also hope you get your broadcast technology working better for you. Thanks again!
Lou
Lou Barba@informationhighwaycardandgiftshop.com´s last blog ..YOU DON’T HAVE TO BE AN ANGEL
Thanks for coming by, Lou; maybe next Sunday?
Ana´s last blog ..List Building- When I Want Your Opinion- I’ll Ask for It… Asking Now
That’s a great podcast, learned a lot about dofollow and nofollow. And much awaited after your weekend trip
Vivek Parmar´s last blog ..WordPress 31 Feature Internal Linking in WordPress 31
Thanks so much, Vivek - it was great being back and it’s nice to see I can always count on your to support me!
Ana´s last blog ..How to Track and Manage Your Traffic Generation Efforts
Comments on this entry are closed.